Wife living separate without just cause

Question asked on: 06/09/2015

My son age 30 got married since last 1 year. The girl is from metro city and we belong to rural area. At the time of marriage she agreed to live in village. But thereafter she told that she will not live in village. Then she left matrimonial home without any reasonable cause. Please advice what step should we take?

Advised by: Shivendra Pratap Singh,

You should file a suit for restitution of conjugal rights because she has no right to live separate on this silly issue. Section 9 of the Hindu Marriage Act 1955 provides right to restore conjugal rights if one party has refused to live without any reasonable cause. Living separate on the ground that husband is living in rural area is not just and fair plea of defense. 

First of all you should try to convince her to start living with husband. If she refuges, then talk with her parents and other elder family members so as to resume her marital life. You can not file divorce petition unless and until a strong ground exist thereof. Court also does not admit divorce petition when there is space for reconciliation between the parties.

If matter does not reconciliate or she refuses to come back on any cost then you may file RCR petition before family court under section 9 of the Hindu Marriage Act. It is remedial procedure for giving a chance to save their marital life.

In the RCR suit, she is has to prove just ground for living separate otherwise court may pass order to resume marital life. Smt. Harvinder Kaur vs. Harmander Singh Choudhry, the Delhi High Court expressed its view that the object of restitution decree was to bring about cohabitation between the estranged parties so that they could live together in the matrimonial home in amity.

Smt. Saroj Rani vs Sudarshan Kumar Chadha  the suit for restitution of conjugal rights is a matrimonial suit which is brought whenever either the husband or the wife lives separate from the other without any sufficient reason. 

If she fails to prove reasonable cause for living separate from husband then court will pass decree in your favour. Court will allow the RCR suit and direct the wife to resume marital relationship.

Ask Your Question

Shivendra Pratap Singh

Advocate, Lucknow

Advice: 16931

Consultation: 3367

How to get stay order against section 125 CrPC

My wife filed a case under section 125 crpc for Maintenance in JMFC Court in the year 2013. The court has decided it ex-parte and granted to pay rupees 6000 per month as maintenance. In the meantime, the Family court has also granted alimony under section 24 of the...

Suit for declaration of a matrimonial status before the family court

What is the jurisdiction of family court and can I file suit for declaration of matrimonial status?Suit for declaration of marital status can be filed before the family court. The Family Courts Act 1984 empowers the family court, constituted under this act, to decide...

Compromise in matrimonial dispute

My wife has filed three cases against my family members in different sections of IPC and me as well as under the Domestic Violence Act. She has filed a divorce case against me in district Ajmer to mount pressure upon me. In the meantime, I have filed a petition for...

Break down relation with girlfriend

She is 16 years old girls. we had been in love for 3 month together and now due to some misunderstanding and in subject to the behavior of the girl i don’t have any physically relation with us. only chat with us, … I feel personal that if I marry that girl ..we are...

Does Hindu marriage sacrament or contract

Does Hindu marriage sacramental or contract? It is now subject of debate that Hindu marriage became a contract or still sacrament. We are living in a new era which is the result of the industrial revolution, the most significant contribution of the industrial...

Registration of marriage

What is procedure for registration of marriage under Hindu Marriage Act? Registration of marriage is a mode of proof of marriage. On adducing the registration certificate of marriage, it may be presumed by the law that marriage is deemed to has taken place. There was...

Nullity of marriage

I am not happy with my wife and I want to end our relationship. I heard about nullity of marriage if husband is not happy. Am I right and if so please advice to end my relationship and nullify my marriage.On the fulfillment of certain conditions Hindu marriage becomes...

Marriage without valid ceremony is invalid

Does a Hindu marriage valid without solemnization of proper ceremony Marriage without ceremony is invalid because Hindu marriage is sacramental rather than contract. Section 7 of the Hindu Marriage Act requires that a Hindu marriage may be solemnized in accordance...

Husband obstructing petition by taking unreasonable adjournments

Respected sir, my husband was taken lots of unreasonable adjournments with a view to delay the judgment in my maintenance petition. I have filed petition in year 2000 and got judgment in September 2015. Court in the judgment gave order of maintenance from the date of...

Husband has left me and making demand of dowry

I am living separately because my husband has left me. One year has gone, but my husband doesn’t want to give alimony or bear my expenses. He is using my ATM also for his purpose as well as demanding dowry from me. What could I do? First of all, you should block your...

quick Advice

Get A Quick Advice

Book an appointment for 15 minutes and consult with an expert over the phone within minutes

Talk to Advocate Shivendra

Book a phone consultation for 30 minutes and get solid advice on the phone

Book it Now