Wife can seek residence order only in shared household

by | Nov 3, 2019


Question asked on: 03/11/2019

My husband contracted a second marriage, and that woman has been living with us. The second wife of my husband demanded huge money as maintenance under section 125 of the code of criminal procedure. She is a very much materialistic woman and also dominating my husband. Along with that maintenance petition, she has filed a case under the Domestic Violence Act.

The Honorable Court has decided and ordered to live in my house. I am the owner of the house. Therefore, she has no right to make any claim on my property. What should I do?

Advised by: Mr. Shivendra Pratap Singh, Advocate

The victim of domestic violence can seek residence order under section 17 of the domestic violence act. The residence order gives her a right to reside in the shared household.

As far as your case is concerned, you are the owner of the house. Therefore it does not come under the meaning of Shared household. If the husband is the owner of the house or he has been paying the rent, then the aggrieved person can claim residence order concerning that house. [Avtar Singh Vs Jaswinder kaur 2015 (3) RCR (Crl) 461(P&H)]

In your case, the husband is neither the owner of the house nor has been paying any rent. The observation of the court before passing the residence order is wrong. It should not give such an order, whereas the first wife is the owner of the house.

You did not mention in the question that you have raised your objection regarding the order. If you were the party in the case, you should have to object to the maintainability of the case. However, the court should also have to examine whether the house is a shared household?

Upon receiving the evidence that the first wife is the owner of the house, the court should have to dismiss the case immediately. It infers that the second wife has been living in the house with your consent. Therefore, the second wife has the right to live in the house; even the order is wrong in the law.

In the current situation, you should file an appeal under section 29 of the domestic violence act. The appellate court will set aside the order on the ground that the house is not a shared household under section 2 (s) of the domestic violence act. Section 29 provides 30 days as a limitation period to file an appeal before the court of sessions. At present, you cannot force the second wife to leave your house. 

Ask your question

Shivendra Pratap Singh

Advocate, Lucknow

Advice: 18723

Consultation: 3865

Section 142 of The Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881

I am a software engineer and working in Infosys. One of my colleagues met financial hardship and requested from me to give five lakh rupees. I remitted that amount in his bank account. I have evidence to prove that he took an unsecured loan from me. After seven months...

Trial of cheque bounce case

I like to file a check bounce case in fast track court. a. Is there any specific procedure for applying a case in fast track court? b. Will I get a quick judgement than the normal court?( I have heard check bounce cases pending for 3 years in normal court) c. is it...

What to do when someone forcefully took signed cheque book

What to do when someone forcefully took signed cheque bookMy friend forcefully took my signed cheque book and presented nine cheques in the bank. All cheques have bounced due to insufficient fund in my saving bank account. After that, he sent a legal notice to make...

When can I file complaint in cheque bounce case

When can I file complaint for the offence of dishonour of cheque? Dishonouring of cheque for insufficiency of fund in the account is generally called bounce of cheque. Section 138 of the Negotiable Instrument Act 1881 envisages bounce of cheque is an offence and also...

Cheque bounce case

Within what period of time can i expect justice for a check bounce case? (either I have to get money or action against the person who issued the check) . a. if he fails to pay, what would be the minimum and maximum legal action against that person? What would be the...

quick Advice

Get A Quick Advice

Book an appointment for 15 minutes and consult with an expert over the phone within minutes

Talk to Advocate Shivendra

Book a phone consultation for 30 minutes and get solid advice on the phone

Book it Now