Terminated my service arbitrarily during medical leave

Question asked on: 30/09/2015

Sir/Mam, Without setting up a medical board, I ( permanent govt employee) be terminated during medical leave by saying that You are not joining to office (dies nun and not release my salary past 3 months) but regular medical certificate (issued by govt authority CGHS and govt Hospital and surgeon ) is sending in office by registered post and medical leave (146 days) and earned leave (152 days) is pending in my account? please help me, what to do?

Advised by: Shivendra Pratap Singh,

Your service cannot be terminated without giving you a chance to hear. Audi alteram partem means “listen to the other side”, or “let the other side be heard as well”. It is the principle of natural justice, it is mandatory for the administrative authorities to comply this principle in their each decision. Decision taken in contravention of this rule may renders it void.

However it is not clear from your question  but I think that you have taken leave without submitting medical certificate thereof medical board had not been setup. Non-submitting leave application with medical certificate or submission of it after some delay is a technical mistake it shall not constitute valid ground for termination of service. You have not mentioned that you are employee of central or state government but in each case basic principles are same.

The leave having been taken on bona fide reason i.e., illness so it is not mandatory to submit medical documents at or during medical leave. In Bhagwan Lal Arya v. Commissioner of Police, Delhi (2004) 4 SCC 560: decided by the supreme court that:

It is not the clear from the documents that the appellant is a habitual absentee…….. He had to proceed on leave under compulsion because of his grave condition of health and, therefore, the punishment of removal from service is excessive and disproportionate……… We are of the view that the punishment of dismissal/removal from service can be awarded only for acts of grave nature or as cumulative effect of continued misconduct proving incorrigibility or complete unfitness for service. Merely one incident of absence and that too because of bad health and valid and justified grounds/reasons cannot become the basis for awarding such a punishment.

You should file a writ petition before the High Court and challenge the decision taken by the administrative authority. This decision shall not be sustain in the court because it is not reasoned, arbitrary and in contravention of basic principles of administrative law. There is catena of judgments passed by the Supreme court towards termination of government employee. Definitely, you’ll get favorable order.

Ask Your Question

Shivendra Pratap Singh

Advocate, Lucknow

Advice: 16931

Consultation: 3367

Stay of transfer

Hello, an officer has transferred from our district who is very good and honest officer. We are very happy because he had taken control over the crimes. But due to unfavourable with the present government he has been transferred. We have decided to file a petition...

Get call details under RTI Act

Can I get call details under RTI Act? I want to call details and tower location of a person because he eloped my sister. He is studying in her class, and both were love to each other. They decided to marry, and for that purpose, my sister always pressurised my mother...

Terminated my service arbitrarily during medical leave

Sir/Mam, Without setting up a medical board, I ( permanent govt employee) be terminated during medical leave by saying that You are not joining to office (dies nun and not release my salary past 3 months) but regular medical certificate (issued by govt authority CGHS...

Step mother sold joint family property

My father has made a gift in favour of his second wife who is my stepmother thereupon she took possession over the property. She sold that property to his son-in-law thereafter my step-sister erected a house thereon. The property gifted was probably our joint family...

Rejection of plaint

According to section section 4 and 5-A of Maharashtra Restoration of land to Scheduled Tribes Act 1974 a land purchased from tribal owner by a non tribal between 1957 to 1974 is entitled to restore in the tribal person by the order of collector. Collector is empowered...

Undertaking must be registered, attested and signed by parties

My father gave a loan to his friend and took an undertaking from him that he shall not sell the properties mentioned in the undertaking in currency of loan. But that undertaking is unregistered but signed by the borrower. Is it legally valid ? According to section 100...

Forfeiture of gratuity without held guilty

I am a retired government servant. A departmental proceeding was pending at the time of my retirement. Therefore, the competent authority had forfeited my gratuity without holding me guilty of proved misconduct. He presented ambiguous inquiry report which is forthwith...

Recovery of past salaries

I want recovery of past salaries from my company. I am working as an engineer in a Ltd company from 2006, from last 3 years financial condition of the company is not good, approx 20 months’ salary is pending, I have not resigned, because if I resign, they will stop...

Unregistered agreement of sale

My friend has made an unregistered agreement of sale on rs 100 stamp paper. He wanted to get benefit from my condition because my property was disputed at that time. After five years from the date of such agreement, I sold that property to another person. My friend is...

Injured in car accident

I booked a radio taxi on 25 September 2015 from Amousi airport to Gomti Nagar. In the mid way taxi driver told that his friend is waiting at vip road and I want to go with him but I can arrange another radio taxi who may drop you at your destination. I agreed and he...

quick Advice

Get A Quick Advice

Book an appointment for 15 minutes and consult with an expert over the phone within minutes

Talk to Advocate Shivendra

Book a phone consultation for 30 minutes and get solid advice on the phone

Book it Now