Paid Advise

Stay of transfer

Shivendra Pratap Singh

Advocate (Lucknow)

Online advising since Oct. 2014

33507 Advices

41371 Consultations

Reading Time:

Hello, an officer has transferred from our district who is a very good and honest officer. We are very happy because he had taken control of the crimes. But due to unfavourable with the present government he has been transferred. We have decided to file a petition before the high court for a stay of his transfer, we want to know that the public can file any petition for stay of the transfer.

Transfer and posting of an officer is the prerogative of the executive. It is an administrative order and the only executive can decide in this respect. However, in certain circumstances court can interfere but solely on the petition of the officer transferred.

Infringement of a right which is adjudicated by the court is an essential requirement for filing any suit or proceeding. A person aggrieved can file suit or seek remedy from the court.

In Sagir Ahmad vs State of Uttar Pradesh 1954 SC: the supreme court of India has held that the existence of the legal right is the foundation of the exercise of the writ jurisdiction by the court. The legal right that can be enforced must be the right of the opponent himself.

In A. Noor Khan Pathan vs State of Maharashtra 2013 (4) SCC: a stranger cannot be permitted to meddle in any proceeding unless he satisfies the court that he falls within the category of the aggrieved person.

Thus it is clear from the above discussion that a stranger, however, the general public of the city, cannot file a writ for a stay of an officer. It cannot be said that the public is the aggrieved party due to the transfer of an officer. It is presumed that every officer is honest and dedicated to the service of people.

It would be very tough for you to prove your locus standi in the writ petition, therefore it is likely to be dismissed by the court. You cannot file writ so leave this matter in the hand of the executive because it has vast power regarding transfer and posting of officers. Government is the fit authority to decide the welfare of the public and in the interest of public an officer may be transferred by the government.

shivendra pratap singh advocate

Shivendra Pratap Singh

Advocate (Lucknow)

You can consult on Criminal, Civil, Matrimonial, Writ, Service matters, Property, Revenue and RERA related issues.

More For you

Can mental illness put a bar on holding sensitive posts?

Question: Can a patient of mental illness who is on regular medication become a member and chairman of child welfare, women welfare, juvenile justice board and handle such sensitive matters? Can mental illness put a bar on holding sensitive posts?  Asked from:...

Encroachment of the public paved road

Question: There is an encroachment of the public paved road. Can anyone occupy a 60-year-old paved public road by saying that this has been made wrong? What is the legality of the road in Indian law?  Asked from: Uttar Pradesh Public road is a public property...

How to get back money from my younger brother?

Question: How to get back money from my younger brother?. Younger brother demanded money from the older brother and gave some amount to him without any  paperwork. If the younger brother ignores or does not return the money, what action will the older brother take ?...

Section 38 of Specific Relief Act 1963

Section 38 Specific Relief Act Perpetual injunctions when granted (1) Subject to the other provisions contained in or referred to by this Chapter a perpetual injunction may be granted to the plaintiff to prevent the breach of an obligation existing in his favour,...

Case filed based on False Sale Agreement 

Question: I am 74 yrs old so don't want the case to drag on for obvious reasons. Hence this query. Never had a brush with court in these 74 years but NOW I have been made respondent in a case against me based on a clearly Forged document.  Bought 1 acr land in...

Kanoonirai has been advising in legal issues since October 2014. You can consult a lawyer through online media, telephonic consultation and video conferencing.