Warning: Attempt to read property "post_content" on null in /home/customer/www/kanoonirai.com/public_html/wp-content/themes/Divi/includes/builder/feature/dynamic-assets/class-dynamic-assets.php on line 2078
Presumption of paternity of child

Presumption of paternity of child

Question asked on: 17/11/2014

How to presume paternity of child? Is there any law regarding the presumption of paternity of child in devoid of any direct evidence?

Advised by: Shivendra Pratap Singh,

The basic principle of law, which is laid down in sec section 112 of Indian Evidence Act, that if a person was born during the continuance of a valid marriage  between his mother and any man or within two hundred  and eighty days after its dissolution and  the  mother remains unmarried,  it shall be taken as  conclusive  proof that he is the legitimate son of that man, unless it can  be shown that the parties to the marriage had no access to each other  at  any time when he could have been  begotten.

Sec 112. Birth during marriage, conclusive proof of legitimacy.—The fact that any person was born during the continuance of a valid marriage between his mother and any man, or within two hundred and eighty days after its dissolution, the mother remaining unmarried, shall be conclusive proof that he is the legitimate son of that man, unless it can be shown that the parties to the marriage had no access to each other at any time when he could have been begotten.

The rule, contained in the above Section, that continuance of a valid marriage will prevent an inference being drawn to the effect that the children born to a woman during the continuance of the valid marriage were born to another person as a result of adulterous intercourse is only a rule of evidence.

Presumption of paternity

The presumption which Section 112, Evidence Act, 1872, contemplates, is a conclusive presumption of law regarding paternity which can be displaced only by proof of the particular fact mentioned in the Section, namely, non-access between the parties to the marriage at a time when according to the ordinary course of nature, the husband could have been the father of the child.

It is the principle of law about presumption of paternity that “Odiosa et inkonesta non sunt in lege prae sumenda” (Nothing odious or dishonourable will be presumed by the law). So the law presumes against vice and immorality.

Case law

In Goutam Kundu vs. State of West Bengal and another, Supreme Court held about paternity test ( DNA test)

  • That Courts in India cannot order blood test as a matter of course.
  • Wherever applications are made for such prayers in order to have roving inquiry, the prayer for blood test cannot be entertained.
  • There must be a strong prima facie case in that the husband must establish non-access in order to dispel the presumption arising under Section 112 of the Evidence Act.
  • The Court must carefully examine as to what would be the consequence of ordering the blood test, whether it will have the effect of branding a child as a bastard and the mother as an unchaste woman.
  • No one can be compelled to give samle of blood for analysis.

We may remember that Section 112 of the Evidence Act was enacted at a time when the modern scientific advancements with Dioxy Nucleric Acid (DNA) as well as Ribonucleic Acid (RNA) tests were not even in contemplation of the legislature.

The result of a genuine DNA test is said to be scientifically accurate. But even that is not enough to escape from the conclusiveness of Section 112 of the Act, e.g., if a husband and wife were living together during the time of conception but the DNA test revealed that the child was not born to the husband, the conclusiveness in law would remain unrebuttable.

Sham Lal @ Kuldeep vs. Sanjeev Kumar and others, (2009) :- Once the validity of marriage is proved then there is strong presumption about the legitimacy of children born from that wedlock. The presumption of paternity can only be rebutted by a strong, clear, satisfying and conclusive evidence.

Bhabani Prasad Jena vs. Convenor Secretary, Orissa State Commission for Women and another, (2010) Supreme court expressed his view on DNA test that ” In a matter where presumption of paternity of a child is in issue before the court, the use of DNA test is an extremely delicate and sensitive aspect. One view is that when modern science gives the means of ascertaining the paternity of a child, there should not be any hesitation to use those means whenever the occasion requires. The other view is that the court must be reluctant in the use of such scientific advances and tools which result in invasion of right to privacy of an individual and may not only be prejudicial to the rights of the parties but may have devastating effect on the child. Sometimes the result of such scientific test may bastardise an innocent child even though his mother and her spouse were living together during the time of conception.”

Conclusion

It was permissible for a Court to permit the holding of a DNA test, if it was eminently needed, after balancing the interests of the parties. Section 112 of the Evidence Act does not create a legal fiction but provides for presumption and this presumption is in favour of paternity. But court may order to conduct DNA test to determine the veracity of the allegations, which constitute one of the grounds, on which the concerned party would either succeed or lose.

Send your question

Shivendra Pratap Singh

Advocate, Lucknow

Advice: 16865

Consultation: 3329

Withdraw criminal case in the absence of accused

Is it possible to withdraw a criminal case in the absence of an accused? Hi Sir, My sister in law filed two cases against my brother which were 1. Warrant of Summons Criminal Case, IPC none 2. Criminal Misc. Cases, IPC. For one of them I’ve received court notice. now she is ready to take her complaint back but her lawyer is saying it is not possible unless my brother visits the court. So can you please help me understand the process of withdrawal and is it necessary for my brother to go to court as it is far from our location. Thank You. 

Limitation of criminal appeal against the order of acquittal 

What is the limitation of criminal appeal against the order of acquittal? If a victim files a criminal appeal under section 372 (provided) against acquittal before the court of session then what will be the limitation period for this? 

My sister-in-law physically harassed my mother. How can I save her?

My sister-in-law physically harassed my mother. How can I save her?

BPCL submitted false and fabricated materials as a piece of evidence: Can I initiate a criminal proceeding against BPCL?

I am a dealer of Bharat petroleum corporation ltd and running a petrol pump for 56 long years with clean records. I was not paid the LFR / commission for 25 years as agreed by BPCL which was paid for the first 2 years at the time of resettlement and quoting the Policy had withdrawn. The value of the LFR amounts to 2 crores with interest. The BPCL officials forced me to lease out the land which I was not willing to do. The Territory manager stopped the supplies on 23.06.2022 and asked not to use the facilities like pumps, tanks and equipment belonging to BPCL. They planned to expel me from my property and to operate the petrol pump under Company controlled basis.

On 01.07.2022 I remove the facilities/ items like Pump, Underground tanks, electrical item belongings of BPCL and kept outside the licensed premise and informed BPCL to clear the items which valued ₹ 17,31,138.00 as per their records and informed to clear the items with in 15 days which was not taken yet. Now the BPCL filed a damage claim for ₹ 17,31,138.00 in the civil court.

A valuation certificate was produced by the BPCL by the manager engineers Mr. Rupam quoting that the items were inspected by visiting the retail outlets site on19.09.2022 and certified that all the line items mentioned in above are not reusable and damaged beyond repairs.  

We claim it is fabricating false evidence, false entry in any book, record, document, containing a false statement. This certificate is produced before the court for evi­dence in a judicial proceeding. He is a public servant. Whether we can file a criminal case in the magistrate court against him.

Justification: The said removed items were not in the premises as mentioned in the certificate. The premises were locked with CCTV and a security guard. The certificate was given to ₹17,31,138.00 of the entire value of items quoting which were damaged and beyond usable condition. The list of items varies physically as time to time replaced items are not updated by BPCL in their records and this proves that the certificate was done on their table. We have enough evidence to prove the same.

Kindly guide us in the matters whether we can file a criminal complaint against the Engineer and Territory Manager who instructed us to do the inspection as claimed by engineer Mr Rupam.

Girl’s family is threatening for love jihad case

My friend is muslim he loves hindu girl. Girl’s family is threatening for love jihad case so he want to convert to hindu religion. He loves that girl and agreed to change his religion. Now he is afraid that the girl’s family may file a case against him and his family. Thereafter, his life will be in danger. He may face criminal charges or police may arrest him and his family members. 

He is Muslim so he is very afraid that Yogi Adityanath’s police will torture him to marry with a Hindu girl. His family is suggesting that he should leave India and settle in the Middle-east. There he will get better protection and he will protect his life from the love jihad. Actually he does not want to leave India. Please suggest.

Offence of sexual assault in the Indian Penal Code

The Indian Penal Code (IPC) recognizes the offence of sexual assault, which is defined under Section 354A of the code. This section criminalizes sexual harassment and includes a range of acts such as physical contact, advances, or demands for sexual favors that are...

My boyfriend is torturing and sexually harassed me

My boyfriend is torturing and sexually harassed me for five years. He thinks that his company has fired him because of me. However, he is working in another company on the same job status but he used to create problems in my job. Every time he proved me guilty. I was in mental pain for the last 5 months and I got to know that he is working without getting fired from job. Can i file a complaint against my boyfriend for mental harassment and sexual orientation?

How to treat unwelcomed sexual gestures

If you are the recipient of unwelcomed sexual gestures, here are some steps you can take: Speak up: It is important to clearly communicate to the person that their behavior is not acceptable. This can be done in a calm and assertive manner, using language such as "I...

Friend filed criminal case of cheating : What I should do?

I am doing a business of terrace farming. My friend is a partner in my business. He does not help me but comes on each week to take his share in profit. Yesterday he filed a false criminal case of cheating in XXX police station. He has alleged in the FIR that I have invested his money in the share market and earned a lot from it. actually he wants more money and when I have refused to give then he has filed such FIR. Sir, please guide me what I should do?

Compromise in rape case

Sir, my younger brother is involved in a rape case. He is falsely implicated in the crime. Now complainant is under consideration for compromise of the case and she is now ready to withdraw this case. I want to quash this proceeding because that lady, victim of this case, is ready and willing to withdraw it. How can I make a compromise in a rape case?

quick Advice

Get A Quick Advice

Book an appointment for 15 minutes and consult with an expert over the phone within minutes

Talk to Advocate Shivendra

Book a phone consultation for 30 minutes and get solid advice on the phone

Book it Now