Legal Advice

My elder brother trying to grab our joint family property


My elder brother is trying to grab our joint family property. He said that the property is a self acquired property of our father. My grandfather had purchased land and built a small house thereon. His family was living in that house. Later on my father constructed seven rooms and a servant quarter. However, my father was not living in that house in his service tenure. We are four siblings. Two brothers and two sisters. Since my elder brother has no source of income, I thought that his livelihood would go smoothly on the rental income. When I got a job in the Ministry of Railway, I sent money to my elder brother and constructed two additional floors. There are five tenants and annual income coming from rent is about 5.6 lakhs. Now he is saying that my father has transferred the entire house to him by a registered will. I have doubts that the said will is genuine. Sir please help.


This is a joint family property and your father had no right to transfer the entire house through a testamentary will. Some facts are undisputed and you have evidence to prove it. The facts are:

  • Your grandfather has purchased the land.
  • He built a small house thereon. 
  • His family was residing therein. 
  • Your father constructed the ground floor.
  • You have remitted money in your elder brother’s account for the construction of two additional floors.
  • Your elder brother has only one source of income i.e. rental income. 
  • Elder brother is claiming the entire property because of a testamentary will.

All the above said facts are undisputed. Even your elder brother cannot say that any of those facts is false. He is claiming the right to the entire property because of a will. Now the question is whether your father had the power to transfer the entire house through a will?

The above facts squarely indicate that the house is a joint family property. Your grandfather, father and you have contributed to the building of such a big house. Three separate funds were used. All the family members have enjoyed this property. Hence, it is proved from the facts that the house is the hotchpot of joint family property. 

Also read: Which property is called ancestral property?

Your father was not a sole owner of this property. Hence, he could not execute a will and transfer this property to his elder son. Since it is a joint family property so all the siblings have a joint ownership. This fact renders the will illegal because the testator had no right to make it. 

You should file a declaratory suit and declare your right in this property. You are entitled to get one fourth share in this house. However, you have constructed two additional floors but you cannot claim your title in those floors. You have shown your intention through the conduct that you have brought them in the joint stock of family. Therefore, you cannot claim that it is your separate property.

Shivendra Pratap Singh


High Court Lucknow

Latest Advice

Builder not providing parking spot as per the approved plan

Of the total parking slots allotted, two flats, 1503 and (705-6) are allotted spots on ‘humanitarian grounds.’ These two homes pay INR 2500+ per month for parking. Nominal parking rates in the building are Rs 200 per month. These houses with nominal parking rates have bought/included a parking spot as part of their main agreement itself. Currently no parking in the building is under stilt or in the garage. All cars are parked in the open and have no assigned/designated spots. In 2017, a SGM resolution was passed to take parking charges from flat 1503 (mine) as part of monthly maintenance. However, since Jan 2023, I have been asked to pay these charges in advance. Parking charges have been paid up to September 2023 in two instalments. Both the above instalments have been paid under ‘delayed circumstance’ due to the ongoing discussions to add, A total of 45 parking spots have been approved by BMC K-Ward and 1 each has been made available to tenants/members in houses with carpet area above 70 M.sq. One of the two houses is mine, aka 1503. (can share the exhibit if needed) My question therefore is:
1. Can the builder and later the society make allocations against the BMC’s approved list? 2. If yes, can I as owner and member of flat 1503 – question the MC/society and get my parking spot back? 3. Can the MC charge different rates for parking spots, those given via agreement and to those on ‘humanitarian grounds’? How do I fight this and what precedences and legal recourse do I have? Details: I am the house owner. The house is in Andheri, Mumbai, Maharashtra The building has two banks – which have been allocated 10 instead of 7 spots as per BMC approved list (can share if needed).

Labours are frequently entering our premises without permission

My neighbor’s plot is under construction, and the contractor and labours are frequently entering our premises without permission. They have also failed to clean up the construction materials and waste from our property. When I asked them to address this issue, the owner of the property used abusive language towards me and my family. Do you have any advice on how to handle this situation?

Can I seek quashing of FIR on expiry of limitation period?

FIR was charged against me on 02/05/2019. I was called to the police station on 02/12/2019 and was released on station bail. They have charged IPC 354 D (stalking through email). But after which no response was there. Recently I got a govt job and when applied for a police clearance certificate I came to know the FIR is pending. The police have not filed charge sheet till date to my knowledge. Can I quash the FIR based on expiry of limitation period.

My boyfriend raped me in the influence of narcotics drugs

Boyfriend had raped me after I said no to sex. I live in xxxxx, I was visiting my boyfriend and stayed at his flat at that time in xxx. We have been in a relationship of 1 year.  We’ve had a physical relationship where we had consensual sex whenever we met. He had been under the influence of Marijuana (and I don’t know what else) when he didn’t respect my no and raped me last week. This has happened once before with him (also when he was on the same drugs, some months ago) but he promised that it won’t happen again. He is a drug addict and takes it 2-3 times a week, at least for the last 5 years. What charges can I press on him?

What actions should you take against an attempt to murder?

My neighbour has attempted to murder in a land dispute. He along with others came to my house with firearms and started shouting, abusing and hitting my gate. When I came out to stop them from doing such a violence, they broke out and beat me with a club and sharp edge gandasa. I suffered some minor injuries on my arm, back and thigh. One injury on my head is severe. That is life threatening so I want to take proper legal action against them. Please suggest what actions I should take against them for an attempt to murder?

India: The Emerging Hub of Cyberstalking

Introduction: The digital age, while bringing numerous benefits, has also opened the doors to new forms of crime. With its massive internet user base, India is grappling with the dark side of the digital revolution: cyberstalking. While the country prides itself on...