Question: My husband has recorded a whatsapp conversation with my mother and is blackmailing me to reveal them. He wants to divorce me because he loves another girl who is working in his office. He is thus collecting evidence for filing a divorce case. I have made some allegations against my husband in recording of whatsapp chat. He is torturing me to reveal them and pressuring me to sign a mutual consent divorce.
Question from: Maharashtra
Don’t sign a mutual consent divorce. The divorce by mutual consent is an agreement and free consent of parties are mandatory for a valid agreement. Your husband is trying to obtain your consent through coercion or blackmailing. This type of consent is not a free consent as required under Section 13-B of the Hindu Marriage Act (HMA).
Recording of whatsapp conversation has no legal value
Your husband thinks that he will take your consent by threatening to reveal your conversation. Therefore, he has recorded your whatsapp conversation. But he does not know that that conversation has no legal value. If he reveals those conversations he will get nothing. Thus you should not take it seriously. Let him reveal them.
You are performing your matrimonial obligations and living with him in the matrimonial home. Your husband has no grounds to take divorce. Section 13 of HMA enumerates some grounds for divorce. Cruelty, desertion, unsound mind, mental disorder, venereal disease are some grounds upon which the husband can seek divorce. Recording of whatsapp conversation does not prove any of those grounds for divorce.
Cruelty and desertion are based upon guilt theory. Unless and until your husband proves your guilt he cannot take divorce. The conversation between you and your mother does not prove cruelty against husband. Those allegations in whatsapp messages are very general in nature. It was a reflection of general wear and tear in matrimonial life. The court will not give any weightage to that WhatsApp conversations recorded by your husband.
File a civil suit
You should watch his activity and be ready to take appropriate action at the appropriate time. If he is planning to marry his colleague you should immediately file a civil suit for permanent injunction. Thereby, you’ll stop your husband to solemnise the marriage.
In that civil suit you should also demand temporary injunction under Order XXXIX Rule 1 & 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The court shall grant temporary injunction as an interim relief. Consequently, in the pendency of civil suit, your husband cannot move forward to solemnie another marriage.
In fact your husband is a guilty party because he is in adulterous relationship with that lady. His act precludes him to avail any matrimonial remedy against you. Recording of whatsapp chat is a mere threat therefore, you should ignore it.
