Dowry death does not made out in case of natural death

by | Nov 24, 2019


Question asked on: 24/11/2019

My wife died of a snake bite. We are living in a village, and there is no medical facility. When the snake bit my wife, we took her to the town for medical treatment, but she died in the way. We did not report the incident to the police but informed the parents of my wife. Her parents were present in the funeral without any doubt towards the cause of death.

But after one month my father in law registered an FIR against my parents and me under section 304B & 498A of IPC and section 3/4/6 of the dowry prohibition act. The magistrate has framed charges against us under the sections mentioned above and me. No postmortem conducted, and there was no dispute about the cause of death. But the magistrate has framed charges and trial is about to start. What should I do? 

Advised by: Mr. Shivendra Pratap Singh, Advocate

Your father in law lodged FIR after one month of the incident. You said that postmortem not conducted on the deceased and parents of your wife was present at the time of the funeral. As per the facts of the case, the death caused due to snake venom. You have cremated the dead body in the presence of the informant, i.e. your father in law.

Delayed FIR

The informant did not raise any objection about the cause of death when he was present at the funeral. After a month he filed an FIR under Section 304B/498A IPC, Section 3/4/6/ of DP Act. He has to place some evidence to prove the demand for dowry, cruelty and evidence of unnatural death. At the same time, the informant must explain the delay in filing the FIR.

In the absence of proper explanation about the delay, the FIR seems to be doubtful. There is to direct evidence about the cause of death; therefore, the whole case is based upon circumstances. The circumstances of your case are proving that the death was natural; however, there was an incident of cruelty. If the death is non-homicidal, no offence made out under section 304 B of the Indian Penal Code.

No proof of homicidal death

I don’t know what kind of evidence collected during the investigation, but at the time of framing of charges, the ingredients of the offence must be in existence. When the informant did not raise any objection when he attended the funeral of the deceased, his conduct proves that the death was not homicidal.

No postmortem report

In the absence of a postmortem report, the court cannot presume that the death was unnatural only on the oral statement of witnesses. Section 304 B of the IPC requires that the death should occur otherwise than under normal circumstances. Without proving this fact, a criminal proceeding cannot sustain for the offence of dowry death.

File discharge application

In the current situation, you should file a discharge application before the court. When ingredients of the offence are missing the court cannot frame charges against accused. If the court rejects your application thereupon you should prefer a petition before the high court under section 482 of the code of criminal procedure.

Ask your question

Shivendra Pratap Singh

Advocate, Lucknow

Advice: 18723

Consultation: 3865

Sexual intercourse by making a false promise of marriage

The Supreme Court held that sexual intercourse by taking consent on the false promise of marriage amounts to the offence of rape. As far as section 90 & 375 IPC is concerned, if the consent was taken by the misconception of fact, i.e. the false promise of marriage, it is not a valid consent and accused shall be punished for the offence of rape

recall of witness in cheque bounce case

सर,मेरा नाम लख्मीचंद है मुझ पर १३८ का एक मामला दर्ज है जिसमे मामला दायर करने वाले का बयान हो चूका है मेने दूसरा वकील कर लिया है ..वकील मामला दर्ज कराने वाले का दोबारा बयान करवाना चाहता है, परन्तु अपील ख़ारिज होती नजर आ रही है यदि दोबारा बयान होता है तो मुझे न्याय मिल...

Bank obtained my call detail record without my permission

Bank obtained my call detail record without my permission. Can Credit Card Recovery department get CDR of any person? I want to know that any recovery agent can call the other person to recover the amount by using the call details. The mobile provider company provides...

Quashing of ex-parte order passed by the judicial magistrate in domestic violence case

I want to quash the ex-parte order of Judicial Magistrate passed in my absence. My wife filed a complaint under section 12 of the domestic violence act for various relief. I was in Canada when the incident of domestic violence took place. Consequently, the said...

Domestic violence by husband

Domestic violence committed by husband in shared house hold. Sir my husband is a sepoy in up police and he is having sexual relation with his bhabhi.I got marry with him on 14 Feb 2014 as per Hindu riti Rivas and his family asked for 10 lakh Rs my father given to him...

quick Advice

Get A Quick Advice

Book an appointment for 15 minutes and consult with an expert over the phone within minutes

Talk to Advocate Shivendra

Book a phone consultation for 30 minutes and get solid advice on the phone

Book it Now