Dowry death and cruelty

t

Question asked on: 12/02/2019

My daughter died in strange circumstances. She in-laws were demanded dowry after the marriage. I could not fulfil their demands but tried best to achieve as far as possible. I have sufficient evidence to prove that they demanded dowry otherwise ready to face dire consequences.

By and large, they were unhappy and called a meeting for settlement. I have so many messages about the incidents of cruelty. They tortured my daughter to compel us to give XUV 500. Mainly her husband and his parents are responsible. I want to know what is the law regarding dowry death and cruelty.

Advised by: Mr. Shivendra Pratap Singh, Advocate

Accused has committed the offence of dowry death and all the ingredients of that offence are exist in your case. You should file FIR as soon as possible. Delay in filing FIR may cause serious impediment.

The offence of dowry death is made punishable under section 304-B of the Indian Penal Code (IPC). Following are the essential ingredients of the offence: 

Basic components

The Supreme Court in Ram Badan Sharma v. State of Bihar, (2006) 10 SCC 115;  has explained the essential ingredients of dowry death as:

  • Deceased died due to burn or bodily injury or otherwise than under normal circumstances. 
  • She died within seven years of marriage. 
  • Soon before her death, she was subjected to cruelty or harassment by her husband or any relative of her husband. 
  • Finally, that torture or cruelty related with any demand for dowry

Time is an essential element for this offence. Death should be caused within seven years of marriage, and such death is the direct consequence of cruelty committed by the accused of the demand of dowry. If there is remoteness of the link between death and demand for dowry, then offence of dowry death is not made out.

For brought the accused in the purview of dowry death, section 113 B inserted in the Indian Evidence Act. According to this section, the court upon fulfilment of some conditions shall presume that the offence of dowry death is committed. Section 113 B ensues presumption of dowry death. 

Presumption of dowry death

Section 113 B of the Indian Evidence Act empowers the court to presume dowry death upon fulfilment of these conditions

  • Soon before her death, she was subjected to cruelty. 
  • That cruelty or harassment was in connection with any demand for dowry

When prosecution successfully proves the conditions mentioned above, then the Court may presume that the accused has committed dowry death.

As far as your case is concerned, there has been persistent demand of dowry and harassment, humiliation and physical violence by the husband and her in-laws. After all, your daughter died in the relation of demand for dowry. She died within seven years of marriage. Hence, it is a clear case of dowry death.

The Supreme Court held in State of H.P. v. Nikku Ram [(1995) 6 SCC 219]; that the demand for dowry can be made at any time, and not necessarily before marriage. Generally, the accused demands dowry on three occasions. Firstly before the wedding. Secondly at the time of marriage and finally after the marriage.

However, to get a conviction under this section, cruelty must relate with demand for dowry as well as deceased being subjected to cruelty soon before her death.

Cruelty 

Section 498-A of IPC defines the act of cruelty. This section extends the ambit of section 304-B. Mere harassment of woman does not constitute cruelty. When the act committed with a view to forcing the wife to fulfil illegal demands of accused, then the court treats such act as cruelty under section 498-A.

There must be some cogent evidence in support of the fact that accused harassed his wife. Such harassment should be in connection unlawful demands like payment of money, delivery articles. That cruelty was committed soon before her death.

Ask Your Question

Shivendra Pratap Singh

Advocate, Lucknow

Advice: 18706

Consultation: 3832

False allegation of domestic violence against husband

My file has filed a false case under domestic violence act. Does the court examine the truthfulness of case before passing any order against the accused?   False allegations made by wife against her husband destroy the sanctity of marriage. Marriage speaks of absolute...

My wife may file false case under section 498 A

Dear Sirs/Madam, I got married on 12/02/2015..from day one we have compatibility issue. I tried to sort it but i got failed. She is adamant; she misbehaves with my family member whenever they come to my home. She did not cook food. Recently we had quarrel on very...

Prosecution after retirement

Can a department prosecute to its employees after retirement for his Negligence to fulfil his duties?You did not mention details about your employment and the year of retirement. Generally, every civil service rule has a limitation period for prosecution of the...

Appeal against acquittal

The trial court has acquitted the accused on the ground of insufficient evidence. He was charge-sheeted by the investigation officer. He managed to acquit because I could not attend the court on every date. The prosecution was reluctant to convict him because he is an...

Elements of dowry death

What are the essential elements of dowry death?Sati and dowry death has plagued this nation for centuries. Sati, the practice of sending a widow to her husband’s funeral pyre to burn in it. It was first outlawed under British Rule in 1829 and 1830 under the...

quick Advice

Get A Quick Advice

Book an appointment for 15 minutes and consult with an expert over the phone within minutes

Talk to Advocate Shivendra

Book a phone consultation for 30 minutes and get solid advice on the phone

Book it Now