Home | Legal Advice | Property Law | Daughter gets right in ancestral property by birth

Daughter gets right in ancestral property by birth

Question: There was a confusion towards the right of daughters in her father's ancestral property. In Prakash vs Phulvati (2016) the Supreme Court has held that daughter has right in the ancestral property if father is alive on or after the date when the amendment in Section 6 of the Hindu Succession Act has came into force. This confusion has been removed by the Supreme Court in the Vineeta Sharma Case. Here the dictum of Vineeta Sharma case has been discussed.
advocate shivendra

Shivendra Singh

Advocate

High Court Lucknow

Reading Time:

The Supreme Court has held in the Vineeta Sharma v. Rakesh Sharma, (2020) 9 SCC 1; that daughter gets right in the ancestral property by birth. She will get share in the ancestral property even if her father has died before the 20th September 2005. 

There was a contradiction in the two judgments of the Supreme Court. In Prakash & Ors. V. Phulavati & Ors., (2016) 1 SCC (Civ) 549, the Supreme Court has held that if the father has died prior to 20-09-2005 his daughters would have no right in the ancestral property.

Whereas in Danamma @ Suman Surpur vs Amar (2018) 3 SCC 343, the hon’ble court gives judgment that daughter will have right in the ancestral property however, her father died before 20-09-2005.

20-09-2005 is the date of enforcement of Hindu Succession (Amendment) Act 1956. This amendment Act provides that daughter will also be a coparcener thus she is entitled to get share in ancestral property. 

When a contradiction arose in respect of when the daughter shall get share in the ancestral property, the Supreme Court (Justice, Arjan Kumar Sikri) has sent the Vineeta Sharma case before the full bench (three judges bench) to settle the law on this issue. 

Judgment of Vineeta Sharma

The full bench has decided the case and has settled the dispute regarding the timing of devolution of ancestral property to daughters. 

  • The daughter will get share in the ancestral property regardless of whether her father died on or before 20 September 2005. 
  • Daughter accrues coparcenary rights in ancestral property by birth.
  • The daughter who is born before 20 September 2005 can claim right in the ancestral property from the date of enforcement of amendment Act 2005.
  • If the ancestral property has partitioned or devolved upon its coparceners on or before 20 December 2004 the daughters have no right to claim their share.

Recent Advise

I constructed my house on the written permission of NHAI : How to protect its demolition?

As per Karnataka state government laws building to be constructed 40 metre away from the centre line of national highway’s road. When we approached the NHAI, engineer provided conditional approval about building construction. He took written statements saying that the owner will not receive compensation for demolition of his building if the NHAI would demolish his building during road widening. We started building construction after getting approval from NHAI. Now the Karnataka high court bench has upheld the government’s law about 40 metre. The court has directed the authority to take action. Could you please guide how we can proceed now.

An agreement to sale holder has dispossessed me forcefully

I bought the immovable property through a registered sale deed. Before purchasing the immovable property the seller made an unregistered sale agreement with another one and gave him the possession of the property. But later on the person who made a sale agreement did not act as per sale agreement. So the original owner of the property sent him a notice for cancellation of the sale agreement. After that I purchased the said property through the registered sale deed and I took possession of the said property. Now that unregistered sale agreement holder files a suit under specific performance and forcefully took the possession of said property. Now matter is pending in court so my question is whether I can lodge the FIR against the unregistered sale agreement person for trespass offence?

Kanoonirai established in 2014. It provides a facility to consult a lawyer through online media, telephonic consultation and video conferencing.

Contact

mail[at]kanoonirai.com
+91-91400-4[nine][six]54